Top 10 Whisky Gifts

[Note: This list doesn’t change much each year, as the classics are usually a better choice for whisky gifts. So, I’ll just tweak this every year and take off the “for 2015”, etc. Happy Gifting!]

It’s that time of year again! For me, the first sign of the holiday season isn’t Christmas lights and decorations going up before Thanksgiving, or the chill in the air, or the leaves changing to gold and red. For me, the first sign is a trickle (and then a torrent) of emails and comments asking for whisky gift suggestions for their friends and loved ones. Personally, I’m a big fan of the whisky-as-gift, especially for someone who enjoys fine food or drink. Consumable gifts in general are a great concept. They don’t take up much room in your overstuffed closets, they aren’t useless decorative items that have to be prominently displayed every time the giver comes to visit, and you don’t have to worry about whether they’ll fit. Below I’ve listed my Top 10 whisky to give as gifts this 2013 holiday season, divided by approximate price. Note that prices are accurate for me, in the Bay Area of California, and will almost certainly not be accurate for you. Sorry! Try shopping around or ordering online for the best prices.

Whatever you’re buying, remember that if your intended recipient is already a whisky lover, you can’t go far wrong with any bottle and if you accompany it with something from the The Manly Man Company then you are really going to score with them. Only the most jaded whisky snob will look down at a free bottle of hooch. Don’t worry about duplicates either – a whisky drinker will appreciate a backup bottle of something he or she already likes. The main thing to watch out for is peat: unless you know that your giftee appreciates peated or smoky whiskies (or you’re hoping to expand his or her horizons), I’d steer clear of Islay and peated Islanders. Cask-strength selections are another thing to watch for. If you get something higher than 46% ABV, I’d include a note that the whisky is best with 10% to 20% water added to tame the burn.

Also, check out last year’s Whisky Gift Guide if you want recommendations based on what your giftee already likes!

Around $25

($24) Rittenhouse Rye 100 Proof, still one of the best deals in American whiskey, although its popularity doesn’t let it languish on shelves very long.

A tasty, satisfying rye. The smoky and peppery tobacco notes balance very well with the sweeter chai and brown sugar notes. It does not have the overbearing sweetness of some bourbons, nor the acrid dryness of some ryes. Not ground-breaking, but very much worth the price of a bottle. This is the kind of “ah hah!” flavor that brings life to the “American whiskey is a good value” adage. Also, rye is enjoying a reawakening in the USA and is very trendy right now.

Around $45

($45) Balvenie DoubleWood 12 year my first choice for an aspiring whisky lover.

Although it’s climbed in price from 2011’s $36, the 12 year-old DoubleWood from Balvenie has become the first scotch I recommend to new scotch drinkers and people interested in moving from blends to single-malts and want a place to start. It has a little of everything (except peat), and is very much worth the $45 price tag.

($45) Green Spot Irish Whiskey in-demand Irish whiskey now available in the US!

This used to be the “holy grail” of Irish Whiskey, and was only available in the EU. Now, it’s being retailed in the US and is very reasonably priced at $45. Similar to Redbreast 12 (also a nice gift in this price range), it’s made using the old “single pot still” method which, along with Irish whiskey in general, is making a strong comeback.

Around $50

($50) GlenDronach 12 year my favorite sherry bomb.

In 2010, the permanent sherried-malt spot in my cabinet was reserved for The Macallan 12-year. Since then, I’ve had the pleasure of sampling several GlenDronachs and I have to declare that GlenDronach blows The Macallan out of the water at its own game: heavily sherried single malt. While The Macallan 18 (although clichéd) is still one of my favorite splurges, GlenDronach’s 12 year is a fantastic whisky with meaty, condensed fruit and big, robust flavor. If you know someone who likes “old style” sweet, fruity whisky, this one is spot-on.

Around $60

($60) Oban 14 year, elegant and refined.

A satisfying dessert dram. Honeyed and full-bodied, it reminds me a lot of white port, but with more bite. It’s hard to imagine anyone not loving Oban 14. I think this is one of the most instantly impressive single malts under $100, even to those not familiar with scotch.

Around $65

($66) Glenmorangie Nectar d’Or 12 year, golden raisins and honey.

Take a single malt already known for gentle honey flavors and age it for 2 years in French Sauternes casks, and you get what can only be described as a ‘honey bomb’ – with sticky-sweet honeycomb, floral heather, and unctuous golden raisins. One of my favorite malts of all time.

Around $80

($80) Glenlivet 18 year, light and airy for its age.

It’s very hard to find a competent single-malt at such advanced age for under $100. Macallan routinely sells its 18 year-old product for $160, for example. That makes Glenlivet 18 a downright bargain at $80. Rival Glenfiddich’s 18 year is a little less elegant, but also costs less. In either case, age doesn’t usually come this cheap.

Around $90

($94) Compass Box Hedonism, unusual and masterful.

If you’re spending this much money on a single bottle, you probably want something unusual. John Glaser’s Hedonism is a blend of all carefully chosen single-grain whiskies, with not a drop of malt. This is a prime example of what can be done with skillful blending and excellent grain whiskies. The nose is light and sweet, the flavor is packed with bakery sweets and spices, and the finish is crisp, elegant, and flawless.

Around $100

($99) Highland Park 18 year, surprisingly crisp and tangy.

Highland Park is peated – but not in the strong smoky style of Islay. Orkney’s peat (used judiciously) lends a citrusy, tangy quality to whisky. This is one of the bottles on my short list of “splurge” whiskies. If I had the money, I’d drink it all the time.

Other Ideas

($45) Redbreast 12-year, bringing Irish back.

Even though most Irish whiskey is blended, a few Irish distillers are beginning to go back to their pre-1920s roots and the way they used to make whiskey, releasing Single Pot Still (an old, but not widely-known tradition) whiskeys that can be compared, favorably, with single-malt scotch. Redbreast 12-year is an Irish single pot still whiskey with a unique oily/heavy body and delicious grain notes. My favorite Irish whiskey, hands down.

($125) The Dalmore Cigar Malt Reserve and a great cigar.

For a true high-roller gift, consider combining a blend of venerable old malts from The Dalmore with a great cigar. The Cigar Malt Reserve was specially crafted by master blender Richard Paterson to pair well with cigars. It tastes like old money, and stands up perfectly to an Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story ($6). Or two.

Or, for a really unusual booze gift, choose a Clear Creek Distillery Douglas Fir Eau de Vie ($46, 375ml). I can vouch for the stuff – it’s smooth and crisp and tastes exactly like a freshly-hewn Christmas tree!

As far as coffee table books with excellent photography and actually useful information go The World Atlas of Whisky by Dave Broom can’t be beat. Another great idea is a set of Glencairn Whisky Glasses. If you’re gifting bourbon, I like to gift a bottle with a pair of simple, inexpensive rocks (double or old fashioned) glasses since that’s how I drink rye and bourbon.

A whiskey scratch-and-sniff book is also fun, just don’t take it too seriously (especially the know-it-all part). Finally, if you can’t decide, consider a Flaviar Gift Subscription. They don’t auto-renew and you can choose how many months your recipient will get monthly spirits tasting boxes in the mail with 3 samples in each.

I’m sure I left out some excellent gift ideas from this list, but remember that a gift of almost any Single Malt will be very appreciated. Another tip if you can’t decide: Take your gift recipient to a well-stocked bar and hold a small tasting (or host one at your home from your own collection), and talk about the Scotches. Your friend is sure to have a favorite, and now you know the perfect gift! Happy Holidays from The Scotch Noob!

Share This!

  • Great list of suggestions. You’re right – you can’t go wrong with a bottle of single malt as a gift. If they like it, well, the gift was a success. If they don’t like it, the gift is still a success because a) they can serve it to guests who do, and b) you’ve saved them the trouble of spending their own money learning they don’t like it.

  • Great list, wish I could find these gems at these prices. Doublewood just went from $45 to $54-60 in my local shops (I have to drive from NC to SC for the selection and prices). The store owner said Balvenie just had ANOTHER price increase…

    • As whisky prices continue to climb, more and more of my “staples” are becoming “splurge” purchases, since my income is not increasing in pace with the whisky market! That said, here’s the list of whiskies that I would buy if I was spending someone else’s money: Ardbeg Corryvreckan, Talisker 18, any older GlenDronach (15, 18, 21), The Balvenie Portwood 21 (which I’ve never had… someday I will!), Hibiki 17 (I love the 12 year, I’ve heard the 17 is even better), Compass Box Flaming Hearth or Hedonism (heard good things about the first, love the second). I would also buy a bottle of William Larue Weller 18 year, if it weren’t as impossible to get as Pappy Van Winkle!

  • Scotch Noob, I would like your advice. What bottle of scotch aged of 18 years and more I should buy. Regardless of the style / taste of malt. Thank you!!!

  • I’m trying to get my husband a scotch whiskey tasting set for valentines day & not sure what a good company/selection would be to go with. His favorite kinds are basil Hayden, glenmorangie 12 & glen levitt (sp?). As you can see I’m totally lost on this subject. Any suggestions would be so helpful!

    • Hi Amy,
      I would suggest Glenmorangie Nectar d’Or 12 year. It’s kind of a “special occasion” (sweet) version of Glenmorangie 10. Basil Hayden is a bourbon, so you could also consider Angel’s Envy Bourbon (which is finished in port casks, very “Valentines”). If your local Costco sells liquor, you could look for the three-bottle Glenlivet set (12 year, 15 year, 18 year), which would be especially nice for a fan of Glenlivet. Here’s what the box looks like. Note that if he doesn’t like “sweet” flavors in whisky, those first two options may not be the best. If that’s the case, try Glenmorangie 18, Blanton’s bourbon, and Glenlivet 15 or 18. Cheers!

  • Hi! My son and husband both enjoy a glass of scotch in the evenings. I broke one of my husband’s fave whiskey tumblers – a Tom Petty fan club gift. Thanks for some suggestions on best tumblers? I live in Los Angeles and happy to buy from any website too. Thanks in advance and Happy Holidays to all!

  • I bought a few bottle of high-end scotch and gave it as a present to a few teachers at a small private school. These teachers are known to host parties and I know they drink. Thus, I didn’t think it was offensive in anyway. However, when they didn’t say anything about the gift, I asked if they liked it. In a flat monotone voice one of the teachers responded that “it was different”. Almost in a complaining voice. In addition, in the thank you card they only addressed my daughter. Is it me or to they lack good manners and taste?

    • Do they lack good manners? Definitely. I can’t say anything about their taste without knowing what scotch you gifted. If it was something with an acquired taste, like the peat in Laphroaig 10, I can understand people not appreciating the flavor. Also, some people simply don’t like whisky. Still, their response was not very gracious, whether they liked the liquid or not.

    • Brian,
      If you’d read the article, you’d have seen why: “The main thing to watch out for is peat: unless you know that your giftee appreciates peated or smoky whiskies (or you’re hoping to expand his or her horizons), I’d steer clear of Islay and peated Islanders.”

      I never give peated whiskies as gifts for the same reason I don’t bring liver pate to parties: it’s an acquired taste and not everyone is going to appreciate it.