The 10-year flagship bottling is aged for 9 years in a combination of 80% ex-bourbon and 20% ex-sherry casks (all first-fill), and then married for 1 additional year in first-fill European oak oloroso sherry casks. For Benromach’s Imperial Proof bottling, which is part of the distillery’s classic lineup, this same whisky is bottled at 57% ABV instead of 43%. This is 100° in British (or “Imperial”) proof. The confusing difference with American proof (easily calculable at twice the ABV) has to do with differences in the composition of the gunpowder used to provide flammable “proof” that a whisky was of adequate strength for sale. We can all smile and nod at the “100 proof” and then just go by ABV.
Sherry barrels used for maturation are sourced from Bodegas Williams & Humbert in Jerez. Bourbon barrels come from Heaven Hill and Jim Beam. For the 10-year, Benromach uses malt peated to a delicate 12 – 14 ppm using Highland peat. This is to emulate the style of “traditional” Speyside whiskies, which were routinely malted using peat fires before the advent of new heating technologies (and new tastes in lighter-style whiskies for blending).
This whisky is bottled without added color or chill-filtration. If you’re looking for this overseas, it’s labelled “Benromach 100 Proof” outside of the US. I was able to taste the Benromach lineup at a recent tasting event in Redwood City, CA.
Nose: Very hot (of course). Orange peel, and hard candies. And fire.
Palate: Redolent of orange peel and orange candies, although it’s hard to taste through all that fire. Reminds me of a mix of cask-strength Dalmore with Ardbeg Corryvreckan, although with far less peat.
Finish: Long and drying. More of the same candied orange.
With Water: A generous splash of water helps bring out toffee flavors on the nose, and makes the palate sparkly with bright fruit, and a bit of earthy peat. I highly recommend braving the full strength for a sip or two, and then retreating to the water.
Overall: A bright, fierce whisky. Great both with or without water, but at full proof it’s a tongue-blinding flashbang of orange oil and alcohol burn that prevents much deeper analysis. I’d call this a bit one-dimensional, but that one dimension is awful tasty. Interesting that the same 10 year that came across mushroomy and wood-centric would be so transformed into an orangey confection when bottled at a higher proof. Perhaps a consequence of barrel selection?
At $90, this is a little steep for me, as I’d prefer Ardbeg Corryvreckan for the same effect with more complexity and a deeper peat profile. A 10 year-old for nearly $100 is hard to stomach, even these days. Still, everyone at the tasting event agreed that this was the star, and the age-statement and craft overhead warrants a bit steeper price tag. If you like sherry and tongue-searing (nearly) cask-strength whiskies, you’ll probably enjoy this one.
When I attended a Benromach tasting last year in Los Angeles with the company representatives, they told us that the standard 10 year and the 10 year Imperial were the exact same juice, and that each version was simply bottled at a different strength. That is, there was no difference in maturation or marrying. I don’t know whether this is still the case today. Nonetheless, it is interesting that you got mushroom on the standard 10: I did too! Everyone there looked at me like I was batty for tossing out that descriptor. That said, I preferred the standard 10 to the Imperial (even with water).
$100 in the US? I picked this up for $88 (tax in) Canadian in Nova Scotia this Summer. The regular 43% is $59 in Ontario tax in.
We in Ontario suffer through a government monopoly and usually pay the highest prices for Single Malt Scotch in North America.
What say you if this was $68 US as it would be for an American Tourist in Nova Scotia?
That’s a decent price! Sometimes those state or province liquor control boards can negotiate good regional prices due to their purchasing volume. At $68 I would consider this a good buy. If the tasting I attend had been selling these for $68, it would have been the only bottle that I’d have bought. (I didn’t buy anything).
As noted, really well crafted whisky I am enjoying every much. Traditional style whisky is getting harder to find so I am ok with the price point. 92/100